Sunday, February 16, 2020

Genealogy, why is it in Arts and Humanities?

Brian Freedland: It's not a causal science, or "natural" science. It concerns itself primarily with history, so I suppose Arts and Humanities was as close as the Yahoo types could come to an appropriate category.

Porfirio Cahall: sure, the comparable element seems to be occurring with all categories. i've got been attempting ask a question approximately regular practitioner Who in "entertainment & music > television > Drama", it rapidly categorizes it as "technological awareness & arithmetic > medicine" and could no longer permit me browse with the intention to set the final type. there is definately some thing decidedly ordinary occurring. Very demanding. additionally, a question I did be ready to get interior the final type, hasn't been listed in its type on the positioning. curiously the only people who can see it are my contacts. back, maximum demanding. to offer a megastar, you purely click on the megastar image on the bar under a question....Show more

Ma! lcom Bourek: It is not a science like anthropology.Social science subjects are a mainstay of many fields of research, used to obtain an insight into a particular group of people in their natural environment.http://explorable.com/social-science-subjects.html...Show more

Soraya Coodey: For all the categories it is the best one for Yahoo to put it Now for Genetics they have a Biology category under Science and Mathematics A lot of people askng questions confuse the two. We get Genetics questons all the time and they really belong under Biology as Genealogy and Genetics are not the same thing. In genealogy we trace ancestry using documents/records.

Caleb Chapman: Genealogy is a very misleading name. Genealogy is the study family history and ancestors, not genetics and genes.

Saran Stealy: Genealogy is the study of direct ancestral lineage within a specific family. It is more than a series of family histories and at the same time not actually related to ! any of physical or social sciences.The research, if don't cor! rectly includes the gathering of documents that verifies the existence of ones family members, such as birth marriage and death documentation as well as other information that could include church records, obituaries and other newspaper articles; as well as the information provided by other researchers and historical societies. It is by no means a Science, but at the same time can be very involved and complex research.As to why it is in the Arts and Humanities Category - that can only be answered by saying because that is where YA has placed it, and in a general manner could be considered a Humanity....Show more

Leisa Brodnex: Genealogy is humanities....................... no it is not a science like anthropology

Dana Russian: Genelaogy per se is not a science. But, like many other disciplines, science is very involved, particulary genetic genealogy.An understanding of antrhopology really helps in finding ancestors centuries ago, or understanding where you ance! stors might have come from (look up "european" tribes as an example), but, again, it is not directly related.Genealogy is too abstract, too subjective. Some of the genealogy books I have read, written by world's foremost genealogists, when digging into trees hundreds of years ago examined all available records, including family Bibles, any type historica record, wills, etc., and would conclude that so and so was PROBABLY the son of such and such based upon dates of birth and names. It was customary for Germans in the 1400s and 1500s to name their sons & daughters after a godmother or godfather. These godparents were frequently aunts, uncles, or even grandparents.In my trees, it is common for a person in one generation to have a certain name, the succeeding generation a different name, then back to the first name. Or, especially with the Germans, each generation having the same name, just a variant: Johann, Johannes, Hans, etc.In other words, genealogy does fit neatly in! to "Humanities"; you can't get any more "humanity" than histories of fa! milies....Show more

Lana Uliano: Maybe you are thinking it has something to do with genes- it doesn't.Genealogy is just family history, finding out about your ancestors mainly by looking for written records.

No comments:

Post a Comment